Speculation on this divorce has lit up tabloid reports and social media like a crumbling marriage in reverse. The star couple announced their divorce in a joint statement, with themselves as well as their children appealing for privacy—as if anything more would be offered to the public.

That fervid fascination is also a product of today’s digital age, where fans, anonymous sources, and unsealed court documents can sway public opinion. Erin Meyers, who studies celebrity culture at Northwestern University in Evanston, Illinois, notes that online factions often develop among celebrity fandoms—a sweeping pit against one another for controversy and anger to create clickbait for engagement.

One such faction rebutted many narratives around this divorce: social media users pointed out stereotypes about women being bad mothers if they partied. In defending her parenting choices, Turner drew scrutiny over how moms are expected to justify decisions compared to dads.

The scrutiny of celebrities goes beyond their private lives and often raises questions that are more social in nature, like allegations of sexual abuse or postpartum depression. It is this nuanced engagement with celebrities that presents avenues for societal topics and emotions to be discussed.

For instance, when progressive voices in the media and public quickly leapt to support Sophie Turner, pushing back against the "bad motherhood" narrative, perhaps this is an indication that society is evolving how it views women’s roles and choices.